Buying a complete bicycle online is, as the kids say, a thing. Some years back, when I first heard the notion, I laughed. I laugh a lot at new ideas in cycling. The universe usually gets a chance to laugh back. It’s laughing right now.
Pioneered largely by Canyon, there’s hardly a line out there that can’t be purchased online. For those purchasing the $1500 ebike that comes in but one size, no problem, other than the fact that if you try to buy pants that are sold one-size-fits-all, the result will render you the laughingstock of all the places. Avid cyclists, on the other hand, purchasing a bike that may cost upward of $5000, will be facing a real decision.
As a fitter, it’s my inclination to suggest to someone to go to a fitter and start with a fresh fit and then ask the fitter to make their recommendation after reviewing the chart. This is, to a great degree, the ideal relationship with a fitter—using the fitting to determine the size that should be ordered. It makes subsequent saddle adjustments and handlebar positioning easier to accommodate, but I’m writing this now because I know that simply isn’t what happens for the most part. Here are the big concepts to keep in mind as you make your choice.
Starting point
For anyone planning to purchase a bike online, you need to begin with data on you. In bare feet, have someone measure your height, not the height on your driver’s license. You don’t have to show the number to anyone else.
Take your existing bike and lean it against a wall, on a flat, level surface. Make a mark on the floor directly beneath the center of the bottom bracket. Make a mark on the floor directly beneath the center of the top of the top tube. Measured in millimeters, that number is your Reach. That’s a number that can be referenced in a company’s geometry chart. Reach is a way express a bicycle’s top tube length without muddying factors of seat tube angle or top tube slope. A bigger Reach number means a bigger bike—a longer top tube.
Measure from the floor to the center of the bottom bracket, making sure to keep your measuring tape perpendicular to the floor. Measure from the floor to the center of the top of the top tube. Subtract the bottom bracket height number from the top tube height. This is your Stack. Stack is a way to express a bicycle’s vertical size, which is a more absolute number than seat tube length. A bigger Stack number means potential for greater saddle and handlebar height.
In the illustration above, Stack and Reach are represented by dimensions C and D.
Armed with Stack and Reach from your existing bike, you can compare those numbers to the geometry chart of any brand out there. My buddy Dan Empfield at Slowtwitch can be credited with devising Stack and Reach because of the difficult in comparing sizes in triathlon frames. It took some years, but the industry has recognized what an objective way to express size it is. It really is a superior way to express frame sizing.
Overlap
The first thing to understand about production sizing is that the sizes are meant to overlap in suitability. This isn’t like buying a shirt in small, medium, large or extra large, where the sizes relate to very specific dimensions. Production bikes offer an adjustability via seatpost height and stem length that makes each frame size more … malleable.
Let’s take Jack and Jill. Jack is 5-feet-9 and has an inseam of 30 inches. Jill is also 5-feet-9, but has a 32-in. inseam. What this points to is that Jill needs a bike with a shorter top tube than Jack will need. She may need a small frame, while Jack may need the medium frame.
The point here is height alone gives you a small window into sizing, but many brands will use height as a rough differentiator of sizing. It’s a way to know if you’re choosing between the small and the medium or the medium and the large.
Considerations
Armed with your Stack and Reach, you can compare that to the geometry chart of the model(s) you’re considering. The numbers are unlikely to line up exactly, so you will need to look at your existing bike for additional info.
Let’s say someone’s existing gravel bike has a Reach of 404mm and a Stack of 596mm. That puts it in the realm of a medium. Let’s say the target bike offers the following sizes:
Stack: 597mm Reach: 383mm
Stack: 615mm Reach: 389mm
Stack: 646mm Reach: 397mm
The two bikes—both real gravel models from two big manufacturers—were designed with different proportions.
Note how much seatpost shows—even take the time to remove the seatpost and check where the max height line is relative to your seatpost’s insertion. If there is deep insertion, that suggests that someone could go down a size if they needed to. If their seatpost is near the minimum insertion line, that suggests a smaller frame size could be suitable.
Note how many (if any) spacers sit below the stem. With no spacers, going down a size might be possible. With 4cm of spacers below the stem, a smaller frame won’t be an option.
Take a look at the saddle. Is it in the middle of its rails? That suggests some room to go up or down. If the saddle is all the way forward on its rails, a bigger frame is out of the question. A smaller size may be necessary. If the saddle is all the way back on the rails, a larger size may be the call.
Finally, measure the stem length, if you’re looking at a road or gravel bike. The shorter the stem (<100mm), the harder it will be to go up in size, and a smaller size may be an option. Longer stems (120 or 130mm) suggest a larger bike might be an option.
Let’s say the original bike had 2cm of spacers and the saddle sat forward on its rails. As a fitter, my advice would be to go up one size to the frame with the 61.5mm Stack and 389mm Reach. That’s an increase of nearly 2cm in Stack, which removing two 1cm spacers would offset. The Reach runs 1.5cm shorter, and that can be overcome with an either 1 or 2cm longer stem. With a gravel bike, my suggestion would be for the shorter stem, which would decrease reach by 5mm, which is rarely a bad thing on a gravel bike.
Can you feel it?
There are two truths that should reassure anyone ordering a bike online: 1) The human body is remarkably adaptable. 2) The average person’s threshold of perception when it comes to saddle and handlebar bar height and reach to the bar runs somewhere around a centimeter. That means that if every aspect of position is identical, save one that’s off by 5mm, the rider may not even notice the difference. Point being: Don’t lose sleep over anything less than 10mm.
Also, don’t be afraid to err conservative on sizing. One rule of thumb I operate by I call Shorter/Higher: Most riders find greater comfort on a bike with less reach and a higher bar. Our sense of style often conflicts with what makes for the best fit.
A more upright fit—that is, shorter Reach and/or more Stack—can reduce shoulder fatigue, make it easier to look around (especially in looking back) and make the bike easier to control by shifting some weight off the front wheel. And here’s the most surprising reason of all: Raising the bar improves a rider’s aerodynamics more often than not, by allowing the rider a deeper bend in their elbows.
Who’s laughing now?
Image: Jenson USA